Best Neighborhoods in Garden City village, NY
25 neighborhoods ranked by safety, walkability, affordability, and quality of life — powered by real data from the US Census, FBI, EPA, and Walk Score.
Best Neighborhoods in Garden City village, NY — Key Takeaways
The best neighborhood in Garden City village is Cheektowaga CDP with a Kurby Score of 66/100. Garden City village has 25 neighborhoods ranked by quality of life data. The safest neighborhood is Elwood CDP with a violent crime rate of 0.3 per 1,000 residents, 92% below the national average of 3.6. The most affordable is Greece CDP with a median home value of $147,600.
Garden City village has a population of 22,871, a median household income of $204,883, an unemployment rate of 3.5%, and a poverty rate of 2.3%. The median home value citywide is $980,600, which is 248% above the national average of $281,900.
Data sourced from the US Census Bureau, FBI Crime Data Explorer, EPA AirNow, Walk Score, and FEMA. Last updated: March 2026.
Top 3 Neighborhoods
| # | Neighborhood | Kurby Score | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elwood CDP | 63 | ||
| Mahopac CDP | 60 | ||
| Miller Place CDP | 61 | ||
4 | Glens Falls North CDP | 57 | |
5 | Cheektowaga CDP | 66 | |
6 | Oyster Bay CDP | 47 | |
7 | Salisbury CDP | 62 | |
8 | Tonawanda Town CDP | 66 | |
9 | Orange Lake CDP | 63 | |
10 | Valley Cottage CDP | 58 | |
11 | Myers Corner CDP | 63 | |
12 | North Bellport CDP | 63 | |
13 | Greenville CDP (Westchester County) | 64 | |
14 | Bohemia CDP | 62 | |
15 | Cutchogue CDP | 60 | |
16 | Jefferson Valley-Yorktown CDP | 61 | |
17 | Brentwood CDP | 66 | |
18 | Stony Brook CDP | 62 | |
19 | Endwell CDP | 62 | |
20 | Irondequoit CDP | 66 | |
21 | West Seneca CDP | 66 | |
22 | Coram CDP | 65 | |
23 | Terryville CDP | 62 | |
24 | Greece CDP | 62 | |
25 | Stony Brook University CDP | 56 |
Rankings by Category
Top 5 neighborhoods in Garden City village for each quality-of-life metric.
Lowest violent crime rate
- 0.3 per 1K
- 0.3 per 1K
- 0.3 per 1K
- 0.3 per 1K
- 0.3 per 1K
Lowest median home value
- $147,600
- $152,100
- $155,200
- $158,200
- $182,200
Lowest poverty rate
- 2.3%
- 2.4%
- 3.0%
- 3.3%
- 3.6%
Lowest unemployment rate
- 1.2%
- 2.4%
- 3.0%
- 3.1%
- 3.3%
Highest median household income
- $170,909
- $161,406
- $147,056
- $146,250
- $145,487
Lowest Air Quality Index
- AQI 40
- AQI 40
- AQI 40
- AQI 40
- AQI 40
Neighborhoods are ranked using the Kurby Score, a composite quality-of-life index that evaluates six weighted categories based on publicly available data:
- Affordability
- 25% weight
- Walkability & Transit
- 15% weight
- Safety
- 17% weight
- Environment
- 17% weight
- Education
- 13% weight
- Economy
- 13% weight
Each category incorporates multiple data points. For example, Safety uses both violent and property crime rates; Environment considers air quality (AQI), noise levels, climate risk, and flood zone status; Affordability factors in home price-to-income ratio, rent, and electricity costs.
Data Sources: US Census Bureau American Community Survey (ACS) 5-Year Estimates, FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR), EPA AirNow, Walk Score, DOT National Transportation Noise Map, FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer, Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), and EIA Electricity Data. All data is updated on a rolling basis as new government releases become available.
Based on nearby amenities, noise levels, and quality of life factors